October 22, 2012

Iced Pumpkin Cookies

Here's another favorite recipe that I find myself making every Fall.  My original goal was to find a yummy cookie recipe that called for pumpkin that was relatively healthy, yet still a bit indulgent and super delicious.  These certainly are a winner in my book and I promise won't even ruin your post-summer diet! 

These iced pumpkin cookies are really soft {almost cake-like} and have a delicious spiced pumpkin flavor.  The icing is definitely the perfect finishing touch, but they still taste incredible without it.  One suggestion that I would make is after baking these, do not store them in an airtight container like you would normally do with cookies, as the moisture will soften them and make them a bit soggy.  I found this out after taking them to work to share with everyone...oops!  They still tasted good of course, but these cookies can sit on a plate uncovered for a few days and still be soft and delicious!

You may have noticed this is a recipe I've posted before.  Well you are correct, however I did make these again with a few modifications.  Instead of butter I used Greek yogurt and they still turned out great!  The consistency remained the same and they were still super moist.  I had originally tried this with applesauce, but I just didn't enjoy the flavor as much and the dough was runny.  I also used a cup of whole wheat flour in place of all-purpose and you can't tell the difference at all!

Now you can have TWO cookies for less calories than one from the original recipe!  Can't beat that, huh?

______________________________

Servings: 18
Serving Size: 2 cookies 
Calories: 75
Fat: 0.3 g
Carbs: 14.1 g
Fiber: 1.5 g
Protein: 3 g
Old Points: 1.2 pts
Points+: 2 pts
______________________________

Here are your ingredients:
Recipe adapted from Allrecipes

1 cup whole wheat flour
1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
1 tsp. baking powder
1 tsp. baking soda
2 tsp. ground cinnamon
1/2 tsp. ground nutmeg
1/2 tsp. ground cloves
1/2 tsp. salt
1/2 cup nonfat plain Greek yogurt
1 1/2 cups Stevia in the Raw (or 1 1/2 cups sugar)
1 cup canned pumpkin puree
1 egg
1 tsp. vanilla extract

Glaze

2 cups confectioners' sugar
3 Tbsp milk
1 Tbsp melted light butter
1 tsp. vanilla extract

Preheat oven to 350 degrees F.  Combine flour, baking powder, baking soda, cinnamon, nutmeg, ground cloves and salt; set aside.  In a medium bowl, combine 1/2 cup yogurt and Stevia (or sugar).  Add pumpkin, egg, and 1 tsp. vanilla to yogurt mixture, and mix until creamy.  Mix in dry ingredients.  Drop on cookie sheet by tablespoonfuls; flatten slightly.

Bake for 15 to 20 minutes in the preheated oven.  Cool cookies, then drizzle glaze with fork.  To make the glaze, combine confectioners' sugar, milk, melted butter and 1 tsp. vanilla.  Add milk as needed to achieve drizzling consistency.  Enjoy!   



Hope you guys enjoy these cookies!  For more yummy pumpkin recipes, check out last year's pumpkin palooza and prepare to salivate uncontrollably at all the delicious goodies everyone shared.

Also I have a few winners to announce!

Congratulations to Helene for winning the Shine Project Giveaway and to Nicole-Lynn for winning the Pickle Doodle Designs Giveaway!
I'll email you ladies soon!

Thanks for reading and have a great week friends!

47 lovely comments:

Anele @ Success Along the Weigh said...

I haven't made pumpkin cookies yet this season, I need to rectify this right away!

Jennifer@ Peanut Butter and Peppers said...

The cookies are adorable! I just love pumpkin cookies!! I must make these and I love the calories for two of them!! Talk about guilt-free!

Courtney M said...

These look so good!! I love all things pumpkin so you know I'll be making them this weekend!

Erin | The Law Student's Wife said...

I cannot believe 2 cookies are only 75 cals. Amazing!! Love the idea of Greek yogurt--I've had similar feelings about applesauce cookies in the past, so I'm excited to try the yogurt instead.

The same mushy cookie phenomenon has happened to me too. I found that if I lay a paper towel both in the bottom of the airtight container prior to putting the cookies in AND on top of the cookies after before I put on the lid, the towels absorb the moisture and the cookies keep longer. The same trick works fabulously for muffins and other quick breads too. That is, if they don't all get gobbled immediately! Not sure if you've tried this before, but wanted to pass along the idea.
Thanks Kelly! You have a lovely week too.

claire @ the realistic nutritionist said...

These look like my 42 calorie pumpkin cookies!! yum!

Danielle @ Itsaharleyyylife said...

wow these look great! and I have all of the ingredients here! I might have to make a batch of these tonight!

Cindy said...

Quick question--is this liquid stevia you used or granulated? Can't wait to try!
Cindy
{crazyloucreations}

Karm said...

Oh my! These look yummy. Thanks for sharing.

Cindy said...

Quick question--did you use liquid stevia or granulated kind (truvia)? Can't wait to try these!
Cindy
{crazyloucreations}

Erin K said...

1 1/2 tsp. Stevia (or 1 1/2 cups sugar)....... Did you mean 1 1/2 cups stevia ?

Kelly | Eat Yourself Skinny said...

Thanks Cindy! I used granulated Stevia in the Raw, the kind used for baking :) Hope that helps!

Amy said...

Where is the pin it button. I am totally making these this weekend allll to myself :)

xo
Amy
itwasloveat.blogspot.com

Vicki @ WITK said...

Two cookies for only 75 calories? What a deal! Love using greek yogurt in place of so many things in baking!

Kelly | Eat Yourself Skinny said...

Erin, nope! You only need just a teaspoon and a half of Stevia in the Raw when substituting it for sugar :)

Helene said...

I am beyond thrilled to win this giveaway!!! I have to say... I literally NEVER win anything!! Thanks so much Kelly and the Shine Project!!

-Helene

Ruxandra said...

These look delicious! I'll try them this week :)

Nicole-Lynn said...

Awesome! Thanks so much! :)

Carroll said...

Yum! I can't wait to make these!! :)

Anonymous said...

How much does the caloric count change with using sugar if you don't have stevia on hand? Thanks!!

Kelly | Eat Yourself Skinny said...

Making these with the sugar instead of Stevia adds about 30 calories to each cookie and about 8 more carbs :) Hope this helps!!

Christine said...

These look amazing! Definitely a must try :)
~Christine

Julia said...

Hey, just to let you know, when you click on the printable version, it still shows that you use only all-ourpose flower and light butter instead of the greek yogurt. I'm sure both versions taste great though!

Stacy said...

Can you sub whole wheat flour?

Caitlin C. said...

These look AMAZING - I just pinned them. Can't wait to make them!

Kelly | Eat Yourself Skinny said...

OH thanks for letting me know Julia! It's been changed and updated! :)

Pretend Chef said...

These look amazing and I love the substitutions. Can't wait to try these.

Lizzy Do said...

Leave it to you to make a yummy cookie that doesn't blow the waistline...and one that you can even have seconds! These look excellent. Have a great week, Kelly!

Tiffany said...

I think using Greek yogurt is BRILLIANT! They look so beautiful, Kelly. Very nice!

Katie said...

Perfect! I've been wanting a pumpkin cookie recipe!

Erika Surmi said...

I made these today! Absolutely adore them!

Erika Surmi said...

I made these today! I absolutely adore them!

Stephanie said...

Totally making these this weekend, they look gorgeous and it might break my boyfriend out of the shell he lives in where pumpkin doesn't exist!

Janna said...

Kelly --

To clarify, why do you only need 1 1/2 tsp of stevia in the raw and 1 1/2 cups of sugar when stevia in the raw for baking is supposed to be a cup for cup replacement for sugar when baking?

Just want to make sure I get these right as I'm so excited to try them!

Thanks!

Kelly | Eat Yourself Skinny said...

Great question Janna! You only need 1 1/2 tsp. of Stevia in place of the sugar :) I simply put the sugar measurements there for those who choose not to use sweetener! Hope that answers your question!

Janna said...

Kelly-- sorry, but it doesn't actually answer my question. I understand that you only use either Stevia OR sugar, not both. I'm just trying to understand why it's so much LESS Stevia than sugar. Stevia in the raw is supposed to be a cup for cup replacement for sugar so why do you only need 1 1/2 tsp for the entire recipe of cookies when you would need 1 1/2 cups of sugar in it's place? (Just want to make sure I don't end up with cookies that aren't nearly sweet enough because 1 1/2 tsp of stevia in the raw is so little!)

THANKS!

Kelly | Eat Yourself Skinny said...

YOU ARE ABSOLUTELY RIGHT! I'm so sorry I was referring to the Stevia extract, I apologize! Yes you would use the same amount of Stevia in the Raw as you would sugar and I've updated it on the recipe as well :) I'm so sorry for that oversight!!

Rachel said...

My girlfriends and I in college use to make pumpkin cookies every fall. We were all so far away from home it was a sweet reminder of the changing of seasons. You have inspired me to make them this year...cant wait to try this recipe!

Brittany Welsh said...

We made these last night and we loved them, except for the fact that I don't care for the flavor of Stevia, in the raw or any other form. What's a good substitute for stevia in the raw in baking recipes? Perhaps Splenda for baking? I don't mind Splenda as much...

Brittany Welsh said...

We made these last night and they were yummy, except for the fact I could taste the Stevia. I don't like Stevia at all, in anything. What's a good substitute? Splenda for baking?

Oh Dani Girl said...

I made these yesterday and the dough was more like bread dough consistency (really elastic-y and thick). It was also really gooey, but I didn't dare add more flour because it seemed like it would be too much. They ended up cooking up more like rolls consistency too and kind of dry.
I'm not sure what I did wrong! I had to drown them in glaze to make them edible. Haha, not so healthy after that.
Did anyone else have this problem or did I seriously just screw it up bad? (I live in Utah, would the high elevation play that big of a part in it?)

Anonymous said...

Hey Kelly I want to ask you a question is it ok to use unbleached all purpose flour

Kelly | Eat Yourself Skinny said...

Yep! Unbleached flour would work just fine!! :)

demilybones said...

I'm going to make these for Thanksgiving. Thanks for the recipe!!

Anonymous said...

Hi Kelly! I am so excited about these cookies but i just have a quick question... The recipe says to use 1 1/2 cups of Stevia in the Raw but onw of the comments says that you only used 1 1/2 teaspoons of Stevia in the Raw... Can you clarify? I am REALLY looking forward to baking these but I don't want them to be too sweet... or not sweet enough! Thanks so much!! Stacey

Kelly | Eat Yourself Skinny said...

Sorry about the misunderstanding! It's 1 1/2 cups of granulated Stevia, not teaspoons :) Teaspoons would be used if you had liquid Stevia....hope you enjoy them!!!

Sue @ Diet Tips said...


I love pumpkin pie so I will probably love these cookies they look delicious and the ingredients make it healthy especially the Greek yogurt with is great for helping your digestion.

Jessica @ Blog-Inspired Cooking said...

Thank you for this recipe, these were so excellent! I loved how they were dense and chewy. After eating several of them, my husband declared they were essentially the same as doughnut holes. Nice!

I posted my experiences making this recipe on my blog.
http://bloginspiredcooking.blogspot.com/2013/04/dense-chewy-and-satisfying-iced-pumpkin.html

I want to try them by skipping the pumpkin spices and add chocolate chips and orange extract & zest.